DHS assures that it will not build on levees crucial to protecting the city from flooding
PRESIDIO — The Presidio Municipal Development District has settled its lawsuit against the Department of Homeland Security over potential impacts to the city’s levee and concerns over flooding in the area with the installation of a border wall.
The settlement, filed in federal court on Thursday, November 19, with the advocacy group Democracy Forward, follows a vote by the PMDD board to dismiss the lawsuit with assurances from DHS. The lawsuit was filed in June, and DHS then issued a waiver from complying with Rivers and Harbors Act, a centerpiece in the lawsuit. Key in those assurances was DHS “will not involve replacement of the levee wall and will not involve excavation or removal of any portion of the existing levees.”
“This settlement will help ensure that vital levees and flood control measures are not jeopardized by border wall construction,” said PMDD Board President Jiovannie Escontrias in a statement released by Democracy Forward. “It’s good to know there are great people in organizations such as Democracy Forward who are so willing to stand up for our small, isolated town. We are proud of what we were able to achieve with the support of Democracy Forward, and are grateful that we were able to protect our communities against the certain harm we would have faced without this settlement.”
In the settlement, DHS stated that it had consulted with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the U.S. International Boundary & Water Commission, both of which examined a “selected design” for the wall and concluded that it would not “impact the integrity or efficacy of the Presidio levees.” That design was not disclosed to PMDD or the public. However, the settlement also stipulates that “CBP shall hold a meeting at a mutually agreeable time with PMDD officials to explain its construction plans for the border barrier system that it plans to build in the vicinity of the approximately 12 miles of Presidio levee system.”
Former PMDD Executive Director John Kennedy, who took the lead on filing the lawsuit, said Friday that he viewed it as a positive step, but that it didn’t go far enough. “It’s a limited settlement,” he said. “In that sense it’s great, but there could have been a lot more on the process.”
Kennedy said that without seeing the wall designs before a settlement, Presidio residents are left with no assurances that the wall will not be an issue for flooding. Kennedy resigned from his position on September 16 after conflicts with the PMDD board, one of which was the lawsuit. Board members expressed frustration about not knowing about the lawsuit until it was filed or taking a vote on it, while Kennedy said those members were lax in reading his legal updates on the issue.
“The lawsuit served its purpose,” Kennedy said, in that it brought the issue of impacts to the city’s levees to the forefront and served notice to DHS that Presidio would demand to know more about the process and possible end results on wall construction.



